Thanksgiving Menu Ideas: The Ultimate Guide to Turkey Day

By
Lauren Platero
Table of Contents
    Thank you! Please check your inbox now for your welcome email.
    There was an issue with the form. Please try again.

    Thanksgiving menu ideas are some of the primary elements that the American holiday revolves around. Every year, families come together to enjoy a meal full of traditional Thanksgiving dinner menu items as well as the fall food trends popular that year. So, it’s safe to say that food is a major part of the equation. 

    Maybe you’re a restaurant owner who is looking for Thanksgiving menu ideas for a limited edition holiday menu. Or, perhaps you’ll be hosting a catered Thanksgiving dinner this year and need to choose what you’ll purchase in bulk. Regardless of your situation this November, choosing which dishes you’ll serve sooner than later is ideal. Now, read on to learn how to create a Thanksgiving menu with ease and efficiency.

    BlueCart - Book a Demo

    A Plan for Developing a Traditional Thanksgiving Menu

    Come November, every restaurant should use a traditional Thanksgiving menu template. Seasonal menus tend to perform exceptionally well to begin with. But when you incorporate a holiday, one that many people like to dine out for, you create a recipe for a super successful day. 

    Before you welcome guests for Thanksgiving dinner, there are a handful of steps a restaurant must take. If they skip any of the steps we’re about to discuss, restaurant operations may not go as you hope they will. From running out of key ingredients to not maximizing revenue as much as possible, there are many reasons why holidays are worth planning ahead of time.

    Learn how to prepare below:

    Consider What You Offer Already

    There's a really good chance that there are already ingredients in your restaurant’s kitchen that are needed for a basic Thanksgiving menu. Sure, you probably don’t have entire turkeys and hams in the freezer at all times. However, you might have a selection of vegetables that can be turned into side dishes. Or, you might have an overabundance of potatoes that you already use as a fan-favorite side dish. One of the best tips that any business owner can implement when it comes to a seasonal menu is to make the most of what they have. Plus, leveraging this strategy will help speed up the inventory turnover rate.

    Come Up WIth a Thanksgiving Dinner Menu Ideas

    The ideation phase of planning a holiday menu is the funnest part of it all. Ponder all the traditional Thanksgiving menu dishes, as well as others that might be popular in your geographic region. Come up with a few options for each menu category that align with the classics that Americans know and love. Luckily, Thanksgiving classics are fairly simple. So, creating a special menu for the holiday won’t require a unique skill set or collection of unusual ingredients.

    Set a Budget for the Thanksgiving Menu

    Once you start marketing to the public that your restaurant will be serving a Thanksgiving feast, it should be no surprise when you land dozens of Thanksgiving restaurant reservations. With this being said, determine how many reservations you'll be able to accept on the evening of Thanksgiving. Then, determine how much revenue you'll need to generate to be profitable that night. From here, along with the cost of traditional Thanksgiving food, create prices for each dish.

     If you want to make things super simple when it comes to pricing, create a Thanksgiving menu that offers a structured combination of food. For instance, each customer might be able to get one appetizer, sliced turkey, two side dishes, and a slice of pie for a set price of $50. In this case, it will be much easier to gauge the money that the Thanksgiving menu will generate.

    Gather Recipes for Each Thanksgiving Menu Item

     Okay, so you know what you want to serve on Thanksgiving. Now it's time to come up with recipes for anything that you don't already serve. If your restaurant employs a seasoned sous chef or a team of different types of chefs, it shouldn't take them long to come up with delicious yet simple recipes. But if you still need some help, we're certain that you can find recipes for anything that you have in mind on the internet.

    Stock Up On Thanksgiving Inventory 

    The timelines in which a restaurant acquires ingredients for a specialty menu will depend on each ingredient’s classification. For instance, all of the nonperishables and canned goods that will be used for the Thanksgiving menu can be purchased about four weeks in advance. You can also purchase frozen foods such as meats, dough, and vegetables about three weeks ahead of time.

    But what about more of the perishables? When creating a Thanksgiving dinner menu, items like fresh produce should be purchased within one week of the holiday. Meanwhile, fresh meat products like turkeys should be purchased no later than three to seven days before Thanksgiving. And for baked goods like dinner rolls and pies? Try finding a wholesale bakery company that can deliver such products no more than two days before Thanksgiving.

    Get BlueCart Resources

    Thanksgiving Menu Ideas to Serve At Your Restaurant

    Now let’s cover the most fun part of planning for Thanksgiving–the food and drinks! Read on to gain some culinary inspiration for each section of your upcoming Thanksgiving menu!

    Thanksgiving Menu Ideas for the Appetizer List

    Before your customers get to the literal meat and potatoes of the meal, you should offer them a selection of tasty snacks. For a classic Thanksgiving menu, several appetizers can include the following:

    • Deviled eggs
    • Shrimp cocktail
    • Stuffed mushrooms
    • Charcuterie boards
    • Mini crab cakes
    • Bacon-wrapped dates 
    • Butternut squash soup 

    Thanksgiving Menu Ideas for the Entree Food 

    There are far more dishes you can serve as the main course on Thanksgiving besides turkey. There are even some that are appropriate for a vegan Thanksgiving menu! Several of the most popular entrees to serve on this American holiday include the following:

    • Roast turkey
    • Honey-glazed ham
    • Prime rib
    • A vegetable-based pot pie

    Thanksgiving Menu Ideas for the Sides

    So, what will you pair with the protein sources? Consider the following side dishes as potential choices for your Thanksgiving menu:

    • Mashed potatoes and gravy
    • Sweet potato casserole
    • Broccoli and cheese 
    • Bread stuffing 
    • Roasted brussel sprouts
    • Green bean casserole
    • Buttered corn
    • Sweet and tart cranberry sauce 

    Thanksgiving Menu Ideas for the Dessert Menu

    The dessert items that you'll find on a Thanksgiving menu consist of the fall classics. These items typically include the following sweet treats:

    • Apple pie
    • Pecan pie
    • Blueberry pie
    • Pumpkin pie
    • Apple cider donuts 
    • Pumpkin cheesecake

    Thanksgiving Menu Ideas for the Drink Selection 

    Last but certainly not least, we can’t forget the fall beverages that are suitable for Thanksgiving dinner and dessert. From the basics to festive recipes, consider adding the following drinks to your Thanksgiving menu:

    Frequently Asked Questions About a Thanksgiving Menu

    Planning for a holiday can be tons of fun. After all, food and drinks contribute a great deal to the festivities of the most popular holidays. However, it can all be a bit overwhelming. That’s why it’s so important to plan things like Thanksgiving menu ideas in advance. If you’d like to get a head start and begin planning a Thanksgiving dinner menu, take a look at the FAQ section below.

    What Are Some Traditional Thanksgiving Dinner Menu Items?

    A traditional Thanksgiving menu typically consists of American classics like turkey, roasted vegetables, mashed potatoes of any kind, and desserts such as pumpkin and apple pie. These items, among many others, hold an association with Thanksgiving unlike any other dishes.

    What Is On a Typical Thanksgiving Menu?

    A typical Thanksgiving menu includes the following dishes:

    • Turkey 
    • Stuffing
    • Gravy
    • Corn
    • Cranberry sauce 
    • Green beans
    • Mashed potatoes
    • Sweet potatoes 
    • Apple pie 
    • Pumpkin pie

    When Should You Start Planning a Thanksgiving Dinner Menu?

    It’s advisable to begin planning your Thanksgiving dinner menu toward the end of October. If you’re just a consumer who will be hosting Thanksgiving for a group of loved ones, you can technically get away with starting Thanksgiving preparations toward the second week of November. But if you operate a restaurant business, you’re going to need the extra time to order sufficient inventory. Plus, buying yourself time will be beneficial for the implementation of Thanksgiving marketing efforts.

    Is a Sit-Down or Buffet-Style Thanksgiving Dinner More Favorable?

    It’s much more common, and subsequently more favorable, to have a sit-down dinner for Thanksgiving. The most plausible reason for this idea is that Thanksgiving is a holiday that revolves around gathering with friends and family. By eliminating the up and down nature that coincides with a buffet-style meal, there is more time for conversation with those at your table. Plus, a sit-down dinner is much more formal than a buffet.

    Do a Lot of People Go to Restaurants for Thanksgiving Dinner?

    Yes, there are a decent amount of people who go out for Thanksgiving dinner. Doing so is a fun and easy way to stick with Thanksgiving traditions, as many eateries create a classic Thanksgiving menu. The best part? Consumers can experience everything from baked turkey to pumpkin pie without a kitchen full of dirty dishes! The flavors and aromas of a traditional Thanksgiving menu without all of the manual labor of preparing the food bring a major sense of convenience to many families across the United States.

    BlueCart - Book a Demo

    The BlueCart App Has Everything for Your Thanksgiving Menu 

    Purchasing multiple ingredients from several vendors can be a hassle on a regular day. But when you're trying to plan a seasonal menu for a holiday, getting a hold of all the necessary ingredients can be that much more complex. If you'd like the ability to purchase all necessary goods and supplies in one convenient app, learn all about our platform by booking a free demo today!

    Book a Demo
    Streamline order management, grow your bottom line, and get back hours of your time with BlueCart. Schedule a demo now:
    By submitting, you agree to allow BlueCart and partners to contact you via phone, text, email, and automated methods,
    including numbers on Do Not Call lists. See Privacy Policy.
    Thank you! Your submission has been received!
    Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.